
Dave Sim’s glamourpuss reminds us of Neil Young’s rockabilly phase: it’s easy to see some connection to the artist’s earlier, more heralded work but the chosen genre of expression is so wildly off-kilter that you can’t help but wonder if this is an act of impenetrable genius, pure insanity or just some obscure practical joke.
Maybe it’s a combination of all three … or none of the above.
Sim himself - or at least, his press release - has described the book as partly a “take on photorealism in comics (starting with Alex Raymond’s Rip Kirby in 1946), partly a fashion magazine parody and partly a ’sincerely weird super-heroine comic.’”
Like Neil Young’s ’80s oeuvre, your opinion of glamorpuss could well reflect your opinion of the artist himself. Many in the media castigated Young for supporting Reagan’s presidency and scoured his defiantly weird recordings for clues of conservatism.
Likewise, Sim is just about as well-known in comics circles for his “anti-feminism” than for the artistic achievement of Cerebus. In fact, the blogosphere has paid more heed to Sim’s “I am not a misogynist” form letter than to glamourpuss itself.
Well … let’s take this opportunity to state The Keeper doesn’t subscribe to Sim’s views. However, we also don’t consider ourselves an objectivist or particularly believe the Earth is expanding. These opinions haven’t prevented us from appreciating Steve Ditko and Neal Adams’ works, so we feel more than comfortable extending the same standard to Sim.
So, is the comic any good?
That’s … tough to say. As a commentary on photorealism, it’s pretty compelling stuff. Sim is clearly working outside his comfort zone as he copies Alex Raymond good girls (A shot at modern day super-stars like Greg Land? Has he even heard of Land?) and his views on the Flash Gordon/Rip Kirby creator’s work are well-considered.
As a parody of an empty-headed fashion magazine, glamourpuss is cleverly packaged and skewers its targets quite accurately. Some of the humor seems a bit obvious, but then again we do live in a world where Project Runway and America’s Next Top Model are considered must-see TV.
As a weird super-heroine comic, um, well the Keeper was a bit nonplussed about that aspect of the book. Was Sim slipping in his controversial philosophies, or is the “story-line” - if such a thing even exists in glamourpuss - exactly what it appeared to be?
(Whatever that was … )
These are the sort of questions that have spun through our head since reading glamourpuss a week ago. Clearly, there’s a lot more on this book’s plate than you see in an average super-hero title. Is it any good?
Well, that judgment will have to wait until a few more issues come out. Even then, the answer won’t be clear-cut.
Kind of like that Neil Young rockabilly album.